It is a familiar pattern in premises-crime litigation. Someone takes a bullet in the lot behind their building, or a knife wound on the sidewalk outside a tavern, and the property owner's defense team begins asking pointed questions. Why was the victim there so late? Had they been drinking? Did they argue with the attacker first? Did they leave a door unlocked?
The goal of these questions is to shift blame. In some states, that strategy can wipe out a victim's case entirely. In Washington, it usually cannot.
What pure comparative negligence means
Washington follows a system known as pure comparative negligence, found in RCW 4.22.005. Under this approach, a jury determines the total damages and then assigns percentages of fault to the parties involved. Any fault attributed to the injured person reduces the award by that percentage, but as a general rule it does not eliminate the claim.
There is one important exception. Under RCW 5.40.060, a person who was under the influence of alcohol or drugs may be completely barred from recovery if the intoxication was a proximate cause of the injury and the person's share of fault exceeds half. Defendants sometimes raise this defense in bar and nightlife cases, so any evidence about drinking should be discussed with a lawyer early.
That stands in contrast to states with modified comparative negligence, where a victim found 50 or 51 percent responsible recovers nothing, and to the few jurisdictions that still use contributory negligence, where even 1 percent of fault can bar recovery.
A simple illustration
Suppose a jury finds that a victim's total damages are $800,000, and it assigns 25 percent of the fault to the victim for walking through a dark parking area alone at night. The victim would recover $600,000.
Outside the intoxication exception, even a jury that placed most of the fault on the victim would not make the claim disappear. The recovery would be smaller, but it would still exist. These figures are hypothetical and meant only to show how the math works.
Common blame-shifting arguments
In negligent-security cases, defendants may argue that the victim:
- Chose to be in a high-crime area
- Was intoxicated or impaired
- Provoked or argued with the attacker
- Ignored posted warnings or house rules
- Failed to lock a door, window, or vehicle
- Delayed in seeking help or medical treatment
Some of these arguments carry little weight. Ordinary activities, like going home after a late shift or visiting a store at night, may not justify shifting significant fault to the victim. A jury may also conclude that the owner's failure to provide basic security, despite knowing of prior similar incidents, was the real reason the attacker had an opportunity.
Fault among multiple defendants
Negligent-security cases often involve more than one business: a property owner, a management company, a security contractor, or a tenant business. Washington law generally requires the jury to allocate fault among those responsible. How the resulting judgment is divided and collected can depend on specific statutory rules, including RCW 4.22.070, and on facts such as whether the plaintiff was found at fault at all. These rules are technical, which is one reason it matters to identify every responsible party early.
Preparing for the blame game
Documentation of the owner's neglect is the best counterweight to arguments about what the victim did. That evidence may include:
- A track record of comparable violence at or beside the site in the months or years beforehand
- Broken locks, gates, lights, or cameras that management knew about
- Security staffing reductions or missing patrols
- Ignored warnings from people who lived, shopped, or worked there
- Opinions from security specialists on the safeguards a careful owner would have put in place
Victims can help by being careful early on. Statements made to insurance adjusters, posts on social media, and offhand comments may resurface later as ammunition for a comparative-fault defense. Speaking with a lawyer before giving recorded statements is generally wise.
Damages remain uncapped
Washington does not cap compensatory damages. Its earlier limit on noneconomic damages was struck down as unconstitutional in Sofie v. Fibreboard. As a result, after any reduction for comparative fault, a victim keeps the remaining value of the jury's award for medical bills, lost wages, and suffering of every kind, without a cap.
Time to file
Washington's general limitations period is three years after the injury for negligence suits and three years after a death for wrongful-death suits.
Working with the firm in Washington
Coral Gables, Florida, is where The Haggard Law Firm is based. Michael A. Haggard practices law under Florida licensure; he has none from Washington. On Washington cases, he teams with a Washington-admitted attorney and, if local rules allow, asks the court to let him appear pro hac vice in that single action.
Among the firm's roughly 500 negligent-security cases is one that produced $102.7 million in a jury verdict, still the country's largest for this kind of claim; that is a gross figure.
No fee is charged unless the client receives compensation. Free, private case reviews can be arranged at (305) 446-5700. Learn more: https://crimevictim.attorney/negligent-security/washington/
Attorney advertising. The example above is hypothetical and simplified, and nothing here should be taken as legal advice. Making contact leaves you free of any attorney relationship until an agreement is signed. Mr. Haggard is Florida-licensed and not admitted in Washington. Results in past cases cannot be guaranteed in future ones.



